I confess to posting this video from Bangkok, Thailand mainly because it gave me a good laugh—an admiring laugh at that. I don’t know the original source, but it was forwarded to me by my friend Matt Harrison, who works on FasTracks, Denver’s mass transit expansion.
A buzzword in Denver now is “transit oriented development” or TOD, where new high density “live-work-play” neighborhoods are sprouting up around commuter light rail stations. Bangkok obviously is way out ahead of us in that regard.
I mentioned in a previous post that many “crowded communities” (chum chon ae at, a more non-pejorative term than “slum” in Thai) are built in swamps. A close second would be along railroad right-of-ways. Walk far enough along any rail line in Bangkok and you will find very vibrant communities living-working-playing not just on the other side of the tracks, but right on top of them. Since life is so obviously shaped by this central feature of each place, communities often take their name from the railroad company or section of track they are built on.

As in the swamp communities, people living in railway crowded communities face two constant threats: eviction and fire. At a moment’s notice they can be driven out. The two threats are more related than they might first appear. The simplest way to accomplish eviction is to hire a couple enterprising toughs with gas cans and a match.
Living in Bangkok, I spent over a year watching an extended family build their home in back of our apartment block. From early in the morning until late at night they gathered scrap materials and assembled their multilevel, multifamily unit. In the hot season, they maximized shade by propping up sheet metal and plywood as broad awnings with open walls. As the year turned rainy, they consolidated the roofing material for max protection, and added walls. Scrap wood smoldered constantly under piles of dirt to make charcoal, which they sold in little paper bags folded from newspaper. At one end of the complex, women and men bathed both openly and modestly—employing a slick routine of soaping over clothes and changing under sarongs.
I felt a certain intimacy with this family, even though after months I hadn’t spent much time with them. I was always going to get around to it. But it was a long getting around, literally—because of walls and streets, it was actually much further to that back lot than other places I spent time in. One day I heard loud voices, and women crying. I looked out to see the men of the family kneeling, hands pressed together, pleading. A Mercedes was parked next to the shacks, and two men in suits and ties were barking orders. An old man of the family started toward them, again asking for mercy. Guns came out.
I remember the quiet helpless rage that rose in my throat, and I also remember thinking of lyrics to the song “If I Had A Rocket Launcher.” The Mercedes drove away. Board by board, the shacks came down. Women gathered pots and pans. By nightfall, the lot was empty. I thought, that’s a tough human price to pay for some new building project. But we lived there another year, and there was never any building—only weeds and the remains of the charcoal pit.
Urbanologist Ron Boyce identifies two powerful forces of space and time that shape the development of every city, from Seattle to Jakarta. The amazing quick-moving market in the video provides me with good musings about the forces of crowded space and limited time in Asia’s shantytowns. Friends have puzzled over why these are among my favorite places in the world. From the video, though, can you catch a glimpse of the vitality, resourcefulness, and close community possible amid oppressive surroundings in the slums?

Scott Dewey
manages/edits Geography of Grace
hung out for 3 years in Bangkok slums, and loves going back
lives in a 110-year-old house in Denver
thinks about fishing most of the time


Comments (3)
That video reminds me of that scene from an Indiana Jones where they get tricked into going into the back of a truck that was disguised. After they get trapped in the truck the market closes around it like nothing ever happened
Posted by Levi Johnsen | November 26, 2007 10:52 AM
Posted on November 26, 2007 10:52
That video is awesome. It reminded me of my visit to Brazil. Our host wanted to take us to one of their slickest malls, and it rivaled Cherry Creek--granite and marble and glitter. But to get there we had to drive through one of Recife's slums. The mall was built in the center of the slum--unbeatable real estate prices, you know. I do wonder which will prevail--the mall or the slum--in their daily showdown.
Posted by Kathy Mulhern | November 26, 2007 12:05 PM
Posted on November 26, 2007 12:05
The story of the family and their home being forced to be dismantled depresses me...then lyrics to that song you included moves me to tears.
Stories are told, images are seen, and voices are heard here on GOG about life in hard places, and the witnesses to it.
Seemingly, there is rarely much we can do to combat the injustice other than to simply journey with those who suffer from it, and advocate on their behalf when we can.
I am not sure what to do with that reality, though I know there is hope in it. I know there is beauty in it. Beauty of the sorts as in the image of Christ on the cross, dying, murdered, suffering with us. I know it's there...truth is, it isn't easy to see it that way.
And when I strive to find the beauty I then feel as you felt when you watched those families being threatened, helpless. Then various emotions begin soaring up my throat and I am at a loss of what to do.
Thanks for sharing your stories and keep them coming.
Posted by Bien One - Surviving The Madness | November 26, 2007 1:09 PM
Posted on November 26, 2007 13:09